Reading Time: 12 minutes
Unlocking Real ROI with Influencer Strategy that Prioritizes Trust, Alignment, and Results
These days, influencers aren’t just content creators. They’re trendsetters, trusted voices, and go-to sources for advice. Whether it’s a macro influencer with a massive following or a nano influencer with a tightly focused niche, every creator brings something unique to the table. And when it comes to building a successful campaign, knowing which type of creator to work with is everything. People follow creators they trust—and choosing the right influencer can make or break a campaign.
That’s where the professionals at marketing agencies come in.
Influencer marketing is a constantly evolving, highly nuanced space. It demands more than simply chasing what’s viral. True success requires thoughtful strategy, authentic alignment, and a focus on measurable outcomes. Skilled professionals bring the experience and insights needed to connect brands with creators who genuinely move the needle.
Because here’s the truth: going viral shouldn’t be the goal. Before jumping on the latest trend or partnering with the biggest name, it’s important to ask—Who are we really trying to reach? What do we want to achieve? The real win is finding creators who naturally align with your brand. Audiences can spot inauthentic content from a mile away.
A strategic approach to influencer marketing means being intentional—choosing the right platforms, the right voices, and the right message for your audience. With the right strategy and the right partners, it’s possible to build campaigns that don’t just perform, but actually make an impact.
At Markerly, we classify creators into four main tiers: Nano (1K–10K followers), Micro (10K–100K), Mid-tier (100K–500K), and Macro (500K+). These categories are generally fluid and can vary based on industry, platform, or opinion. For the sake of this blog post, this is how they will be defined.
What type of creator is right for my campaign?
So, you’re ready to dive into influencer marketing? But now you’re probably wondering: What type of influencer is right for my campaign? Here’s the thing–there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Every brand has different goals, audiences, and messaging, which means your ideal influencer partner might look totally different from someone else’s.
Finding the right creator is the foundation of any successful influencer marketing campaign. The success of your campaign depends on aligning the right kind of influencer with your brand’s mission and audience1. Are you trying to build massive awareness? Drive deeper engagement? Or connect with a niche group ready to convert? Whatever your goal, understanding the unique strengths of macro, mid-tier, micro, and nano influencers will help you make the smartest call.
Let’s break it down.
Macro & Mid-tier Influencers (100K – 500K+ followers)
Macro creators are the heavy hitters – think 500,000+ followers. They sit at the top of the influencer food chain, and for good reason. With massive reach and curated content, their posts have the power to land on hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of feeds. If your goal is purely brand awareness, macro creators are your go-to. They’re ideal for getting eyes on your product and making a splash in a big way.
A great example of this in action is the Nike Running ambassador program, which shows how a brand can effectively leverage all levels of influencers—macro, mid-tier, and micro—to create a powerful, full-funnel marketing strategy. At the top, Nike partners with macro creators like elite athletes, celebrities, and cultural figures who have over 500,000 followers. These high-profile influencers generate massive reach through professionally curated content, product launches, and viral campaigns, making them ideal for driving broad brand awareness. Simultaneously, Nike incorporates mid-tier creators—those with 100,000 to 500,000 followers—such as niche athletes and fitness influencers who maintain loyal, engaged communities. These creators help Nike connect with more specific audiences and add credibility through interactive content like workouts, product reviews, and social challenges. At the grassroots level, Nike works with micro influencers, including local trainers, community leaders, and everyday athletes with under 100,000 followers. These individuals share personal, authentic stories and inspire trust within their tight-knit circles. This tiered approach not only showcases the strength of macro influencers but also highlights the crucial role that mid-tier and micro creators play in building trust and engagement at different levels. While macro creators generate mass awareness, brands like Nike understand that sustainable influence also comes from creators who strike a balance between scale and relatability. That’s where mid-tier influencers come in.
Mid-tier creators, those with 100,000 to 500,000 followers, hit the sweet spot in influencer marketing. They offer the ideal balance between the broad reach of macro influencers and the close-knit, loyal communities of micro creators. What makes them stand out isn’t just their audience size, it’s the strength of the connection they have with their followers and the quality of the content they produce. These creators often invest more in storytelling, visuals, and editing, making their content feel polished yet still personal and relatable.
They’re big enough to build brand awareness at scale, yet still small enough to drive meaningful engagement and conversions. Why? Because their smaller size often means they’ve built stronger, more personal connections with their audience. Their followers trust them, not just as entertainers or creators, but as authentic sources of advice. Many of these influencers have spent years nurturing communities, consistently recommending products that resonate with their audience. Over time, this conditions their followers to see them as reliable guides. When mid-tier creators recommend a product that works, that trust and credibility deepens, and audiences become more willing to try what they endorse in the future.
A huge part of what makes mid-tier creators so effective is the strength of parasocial relationships, those one-sided connections where followers feel a genuine personal bond with the influencer. In fact, many people turn to their favorite creators like a personalized Google search, relying on them for product recommendations, reviews, and real opinions. That blend of high-quality content, trust, and buying behavior creates a powerful formula for ROI, especially when your goal is more than just visibility.
Micro & Nano Influencers (1k – 100k followers)
Micro and Nano creators—those with 1,000 to 100,000 followers—are ideal for brands focused on engagement, content volume, and cost-effective conversion. These influencers typically have niche, highly engaged communities built around shared interests, values, or lifestyles. Their content doesn’t just get seen—it resonates.
What sets them apart is their high trust factor. Their followers see them as peers, not celebrities, which makes their recommendations feel personal and persuasive. This level of intimacy often drives deep engagement and meaningful conversions. Their frequent interactions foster trust and relatability, making their recommendations feel genuine, not promotional2.
But the real advantage here? Affordability and scale. Micro and Nano influencer partnerships are also incredibly cost-effective3. Offering brands the opportunity to activate a larger number of creators within a reasonable budget. The ability to work with multiple creators means you can amplify your message across various niches and still benefit from the strong trust these influencers have cultivated with their communities. This is especially valuable for companies looking to generate a high volume of authentic content that can be repurposed across paid media, email, or organic social media, with more flexible usage rights terms than you might get with larger creators.
Many of these creators are open to collaborating in exchange for free products or small fees, and since some don’t have agents, brands can work with them directly, making the process faster and more flexible. While their reach is more limited compared to macro influencers, their impact within a focused audience is powerful—making them especially valuable for local businesses, niche brands, or startups looking to grow through organic, authentic engagement.
Another major advantage? These partnerships often have long-term potential. Brands can build sustainable, loyal relationships with creators whose audiences are just as loyal in return, even as they continue to build their audience over time.
That said, it’s important to acknowledge the trade-offs. Micro and Nano creators won’t deliver the same visibility as larger influencers—but what they lack in scale, they make up for in authenticity, connection, and influence within a focused community4.
When partnering with smaller creators, shared values between your brand and the influencer are essential. Their highly engaged audiences can easily spot when something feels off or out of character. But when there’s alignment, the result is powerful, authentic storytelling that truly resonates.
A great example of this is Waterboy, a hydration brand that took a refreshingly grounded approach to influencer marketing. Instead of pouring resources into a large, high-profile campaign, they opted for a more intimate, customer-focused brand trip. They invited a select group of customers who already loved and used the product—not because of their follower count, but because they were genuinely loyal users who reflected the brand’s tone, audience, and values.
What made the campaign stand out was its genuine, community-driven vibe. The trip wasn’t overproduced or flashy—it was all about real connections, shared experiences, and everyday moments that felt authentic to both the customers and the brand’s audience. The content that came out of it was relatable, engaging, and deeply aligned with the brand.
The result? Highly engaged content, authentic word-of-mouth, and long-term relationships that went far beyond the trip itself. It’s a powerful reminder that you don’t need Macro creators to make a meaningful impact—especially when your focus is on deeper engagement and building community, not just broad reach. For brands aiming to foster loyalty and drive conversions, this kind of customer-first strategy can be incredibly effective.
When Brands Get It Wrong
While some brands are leaning into authentic, community-driven strategies, others risk feeling out of touch by prioritizing flash over meaning. Take Poppi’s recent vending machine stunt, for example. The brand sent oversized, fully stocked vending machines to a handful of popular macro creators during the Super Bowl. While the stunt was visually impressive and clearly designed to spark attention, it quickly came across as flashy and misaligned with what consumers perceive as Poppi’s authenticity-driven, wellness-focused identity. What’s fascinating is that Poppi never explicitly positioned itself as a paragon of authenticity, but that’s the label its community assigned it. It’s a reminder that consumers often project values onto brands, consciously or not, and then expect them to uphold those values. In today’s landscape, where authenticity is highly prized, even unintended disconnects can harm a brand.
What was meant to be a fun activation ended up feeling tone-deaf, more like a spectacle than a sincere gesture. It lacked a real connection to Poppi’s core mission of gut health and transparency, and instead of fostering community, it seemed to cater to hype and optics. For a brand whose audience values realness, purpose, and accessibility, the stunt felt disconnected and performative.To move beyond surface-level moments and foster genuine engagement, Poppi should consider partnering with creators who embody the community it stands for—namely, micro and nano influencers.
Tarte’s Dubai influencer trip is another prime example of how bigger isn’t always better when it comes to influencer marketing. The brand flew top beauty influencers to Dubai for a luxury experience complete with stunning backdrops, curated activities, and endless shareable moments. The goal was clear: generate buzz, produce aspirational content, and position Tarte as a fun, elevated brand.
And while it definitely got people talking, not all the attention was positive. The campaign reached millions, but many followers felt the extravagant nature of the trip was out of touch with the realities of Tarte’s average consumer. The issue wasn’t necessarily the macro creators themselves—it was how the campaign was designed. The trip, in all its luxury, made the influencers feel more like scripted commercials than real people with relatable routines or preferences. For the everyday beauty shopper, the content felt inaccessible and overly polished, which made the endorsements easy to question.
This highlights a challenge with macro influencers: their large audiences give them impressive reach, but they can also feel distant from the average consumer. As a result, their endorsements sometimes read more like ads than genuine recommendations, especially in campaigns that lean heavily into spectacle. By contrast, mid-tier or micro creators often come across as more sincere, more grounded, and more believable in their product use, simply because they’re closer to the consumer in both tone and lifestyle.
Tarte may have succeeded in grabbing attention, but the disconnect between the campaign and the consumer experience dulled its impact. This is where pairing macro influencers with mid-tier creators could have helped. While the macros deliver wide reach and aspirational content, mid-tier influencers offer a more relatable, down-to-earth approach, creating a better balance between broad visibility and authenticity. It’s a reminder that, sometimes, broad awareness isn’t enough if it doesn’t connect with the right people in the right way.
Before You Partner: Strategy Essentials
Now that you’ve got a solid grasp of the influencer ecosystem, here are a few key factors to consider when deciding which influencer tier is the best fit for your campaign.
Number one – consider your budget. While macro creators bring massive reach, they also come with a higher price tag—both for their content and usage rights (a legal agreement between the influencer and brand to establish how the content will be used and for how long). It’s important to clearly define how you plan to use the content and for how long, as these factors can quickly drive up costs. The larger the creator,, the more you may need to compromise on usage terms to stay within your budget.
If you’re looking for broader reach without the premium price, mid-tier creators are a great alternative. They still offer significant exposure but with a more favorable return on investment.
On a tighter budget? Micro and nano creators are the most cost-effective option – and they’re often the most impactful when it comes to engagement. Their followers are more likely to interact, trust, and convert. Just remember: when reviewing smaller creators, engagement rate (a metric used to measure the level of interaction that content receives from an audience) matters more than follower count5. There’s a common misconception that bigger numbers mean bigger influence – but in reality, a highly engaged audience is a much stronger indicator of success.
Second, know your target audience. Macro and mid-tier influencers are a great fit for campaigns that need to reach a wide variety of niches and demographics. Their large followings make them perfect for spreading your message far and wide. However, if your product serves a more specialized market such as eco-conscious parents, clean beauty enthusiasts, or gluten-free foodies, then micro and nano influencers are where you’ll find the most impact. These creators connect with highly specific communities – whether it’s fitness enthusiasts, gamers, moms, or skincare aficionados – and they can help ensure your message resonates with the right people.
Let’s Talk Results: When Smaller Creators Delivered Big
While macro creators are often the most sought after in influencer marketing, when it comes to real results, sometimes the smaller creators are where the magic happens. It’s important for brands to assess their campaign goals, budget and target audience when deciding who to partner with. Success in an influencer marketing campaign comes down to strategy–not just follower count or going viral. Some of our best campaigns—like the ones we did with The Phoenix and GROWL—demonstrated just how effective a strategic approach can be. These smaller creators connected with their communities in a real way and helped deliver results that felt genuine. Going viral is fun, but building something that actually effectively reaches your audience? That’s where strategic partnerships come in.
The Phoenix
For The Phoenix, a sober active community, the goal was to build awareness and drive app downloads through authentic, local engagement. We partnered with 38 creators across all tiers– nano, micro, mid-tier, and macro over a 9-month campaign. Despite partnering with a wide range of influencers, the micro and nano creators outperformed the larger creators in both engagement and creating a sense of community. One nano creator with under 5,000 followers was able to reach over a 1,000% engagement rate and successfully encouraged her audience to attend a Phoenix MOVES event in person.
Why do we think the smaller creators performed so well? The Phoenix’s message is centered around community and authentic connection–something niche and trusted creators can deliver more effectively than a general macro influencer. Our Phoenix campaign is a perfect example of how niche and small influencers create authentic connections with their audience, driving stronger results. Partnering with smaller creators allowed the campaign messaging to reach the right audience, further proving that strategy and natural alignment hold more weight than follower count.
GROWL
Throughout our GROWL campaign, we have partnered with a range of 6 mid-tier and macro influencers to build hype for the new product set to launch April 2025. Markerly was looking to partner with credible fitness & tech enthusiasts that could effectively raise awareness for the new product. It may seem obvious to lean on a macro creator to build hype and mass exposure, but our campaign results told a different story.
Our top performers weren’t the ones with the largest reach–they were mid-tier influencers with loyal audiences who trusted their recommendations. Both influencers delivered engagement rates over 100%, along with impressive conversion numbers, proving that influence isn’t just about reach–it’s about engagement.
What made the mid-tier creators stand out? The campaign messaging was a great fit for mid-tier creators as it was specific enough for a niche audience and broad enough to appeal to a larger community. Both of these creators produced professional, high quality content while still remaining authentic and connecting with their audience. The GROWL campaign is a great example of why strategy matters when it comes to influencer marketing campaigns. While some may think macro creators are best for mass exposure and building hype, it’s important for brands to take their campaign messaging and goals into account. GROWL proved that success doesn’t come from the biggest influencers, but from the ones who actually connect with the audience.
Both The Phoenix and the GROWL campaigns prove that it is more important to focus on strategy and engagement rather than follower count. Whether it’s a nano creator strengthening a community or a mid-tier influencer driving conversions through high quality content, success comes from natural alignment through the brand, message, & creator. As engagement continues to outweigh follower count in importance, brands that take a strategic, thoughtful approach will continue to see the most return.
To Wrap This Up
In influencer marketing, success isn’t just about picking the biggest creators; it’s about aligning the right influencer with your campaign’s goals, budget, and audience. Whether you’re looking to build broad awareness with macro influencers like Nike’s Ambassador campaign, or foster deeper engagement with micro and nano creators like Waterboy’s intimate brand experience, the key is authenticity and relevance. Choosing the right creator for your brand requires strategy, not just reaching for the largest follower count. By focusing on the right fit, based on engagement, trust, and shared values, you can drive real results that go beyond viral moments and lead to lasting brand connections.
At Markerly, we understand that the influencer marketing landscape is constantly evolving, and navigating it can be overwhelming. That’s where we come in. As specialists in influencer marketing, we combine deep industry knowledge with data-driven strategy to match your brand with creators who will truly move the needle. From campaign ideation to execution and analysis, we manage the entire process, from initial outreach to final reporting, so you can focus on results. With Markerly, your investment is backed by strategy, streamlined execution, and a commitment to long-term value and measurable impact.
2https://www.voguebusiness.com/story/beauty/how-nano-creators-became-beautys-best-marketing-tool
4https://biliate.com/2024/09/20/niche-influencer-marketing-for-brands
